Are Any Dog Toys Actually Indestructible?

Are Any Dog Toys Actually Indestructible?

The Myth of Indestructible Dog Toys

Let’s be honest, no dog toy is truly indestructible. Our furry friends have a knack for turning even the toughest toys into confetti. But hey, that’s part of the fun, right? So, if you’re on a quest to find the Holy Grail of durable dog toys, you’re in the right place.

Are there any indestructible dog toys out there?

Spoiler Alert: No dog toy is completely indestructible, but don't throw in the chew towel just yet! Our furry friends might be experts in toy destruction, but we've found some tough cookies that can outlast the rest. A truly indestructible toy could be dangerous, posing a risk to their teeth and health. Here's the twist — think of dog toys as being designed to last as long as your pup wants them to, making it essential to strike the perfect balance between fun and durability.

The Reality Behind Indestructible Claims

The term "indestructible" can be misleading when it comes to dog toys. While many toys are marketed as tough and durable, no toy can withstand every dog's chewing habits indefinitely. Dogs, especially power chewers, can eventually break down even the most robust toys.

Tip: Remember, the goal isn’t to find a toy that will last forever, but to find one that provides a fun, challenging, and safe playtime experience for your pup.
Dog Defluffing Nearly Indestructible Dog Toy

Types of Durable Dog Toys

Rubber Chew Toys: Pros and Cons


  • Durable: Thick and high quality natural rubber toys can usually withstand heavy chewing and aggressive play.
  • Flexible: Rubber material is a bit more malleable and gentle on your dog’s teeth and gums than some of the harder toys for tough chewers.
  • Bouncy: Most rubber toys are great for fetch games, adding an extra layer of fun.
  • Easy to Clean: Most natural rubber toys are usually dishwasher safe on the top rack, making cleaning a breeze.


  • Heaviness: Some rubber toys can be too heavy for smaller dogs, and they may not show as much interest in playing them.
  • Smell: New rubber toys may have a strong rubber odor.
  • Chewing Challenge: Extremely aggressive chewers can eventually rip and break pieces off.

Nylon Chew Toys: Pros and Cons


  • Super Tough: Nylon toys can last a long time, even with aggressive chewers, making them a good choice if you are looking for a nearly indestructible toy.
  • Variety: Comes in many different shapes, sizes and flavors to keep your dog interested.
  • Dental Benefits: Chewing can help clean teeth and control plaque.


  • Hard Texture: As much as they can be good for cleaning, nylon toys can also be hard on your dog’s teeth, especially for puppies and older dogs.
  • Floor and Wall Damage: Dropping a nylon toy on your hardwood or ceramic tiles can cause damage to your floor and walls.
  • Interest Levels: Not all dogs enjoy the hard texture and may not be interested in chewing on them.

Reinforced Rope Toys: Pros and Cons


  • Gentle on Teeth: Rope toys are softer than rubber and nylon, making them great for light chewing and interactive play. Cotton ropes offer great teeth cleaning as well.
  • Interactive Play: Ideal for indoor and outdoor games of tug-of-war to bond with your dog.
  • Variety: Available in many sizes, lengths, and thicknesses to suit different breeds and chewing needs.


  • Shredding Risk: Aggressive chewers can shred and pluck at rope strands easily, potentially swallowing the fibers. Playtime should always be monitored.
  • Messy: Can leave rope fibers around your home that you will need to pickup or vacuum after.
  • Durability: If left out like a regular toy, it may not last as long as other tough toys.

Multi-Layered Toys: Pros and Cons


  • Dual Layers: Outer layer is fun to destroy, while the inner layer is tough and long-lasting.
  • Engaging: Keeps dogs entertained by providing a challenge to get to the inner layer.
  • Upgraded Durability: The durable rubber core provides extra durability, making 2 in 1 toys longer lasting and better value.


  • Possible Bad Encouragement: Some feel that allowing or encouraging your dog to destroy a toy can be bad encouragement.
  • Price: Can be more expensive due to the dual-layer design.
  • Supervision Needed: Pieces of the outer layer can become a choking hazard if not closely monitored. You should always supervise playtime with any toy.

How to Choose the Best Tough Toys

Picking the right toy for your power chewer can feel like navigating a minefield. But don’t worry, we’ve got your back. Here’s what you need to know to make the best choice for your furry friend.

Size Matters: Picking the Right Size

Why is size so important? The size of the toy should match the size of your dog. Toys that are too small can be a potential choking hazard, while oversized toys may be difficult for your dog to use and handle.

If you are unsure whether a toy is too big or too small, it is recommended to size up. Larger toys can be more difficult for your dog to destroy, making them longer lasting and saving you money!

Quality vs. Cost

Higher quality toys tend to be more expensive, but they often last longer and provide better value in the long run. Look for toys made from durable materials like rubber, nylon, or tough fabrics. Avoid toys with small parts that can be easily torn off and swallowed.

Why Some Toys Last Longer Than Others

Toys designed with power chewers in mind often have reinforced seams, multiple layers of material, and are made from tough materials. It is important to understand that even toys labelled as "Indestructible" will eventually wear down and possibly get destroyed over time.

How to Get More Out of Your Dog Toys

Training Tips for Destructive Chewers

  • Start with Supervision: Supervise your dog when introducing a new toy and monitor their chewing habits.
  • Redirect Chewing: If your dog starts chewing on a new toy inappropriately or aggressively, give them a gentle tap to distract and redirect them to use their toy and praise them for chewing it.

Understanding Your Dog's Chewing Habits

  • Identify your Dog's Chewing Type: Determine if your dog is a nibbler, an aggressive chewer, or somewhere in between. This will help you select the right toys.
  • Age and Breed Considerations: Puppies and older dogs may have different chewing needs. Similarly, certain breeds are more prone to aggressive chewing than others.

Toy Rotation

  • Variety is Key: Keep a variety of toys and rotate them weekly to keep your dog engaged and prevent them from getting bored.
  • Extend Toy Life: Rotating toys can extend their life by giving them a break from constant use, reducing wear and tear.

Dog Toy Safety Tips

When it comes to keeping your furry friend happy and safe, picking the right toy is just the beginning. Here are some key tips to ensure your dog’s playtime is both fun and secure.

The Importance of Supervising Your Dog

While it’s tempting to let your dog play unattended, supervision is crucial. Keeping an eye on your pup while they play can prevent accidents, like choking on small parts or ingesting something harmful. Plus, it's a great way to bond and enjoy some quality time together.

Regularly Inspect Toys

Toys can wear out over time (Yes, even the indestructible ones), especially with a power chewer in the house. Make it a habit to regularly check your dog’s toys for signs of damage or wear. If a toy starts to fall apart, it’s time to retire it. This ensures your dog doesn’t swallow any loose pieces, keeping playtime safe and fun.

Health Benefits of Chew Toys

Chew toys aren’t just for entertainment—they're great for your dog's health too! They help keep teeth clean, reduce plaque and tartar build-up, and satisfy your dog’s natural chewing instincts. Plus, chewing can be a great stress reliever, providing mental stimulation that keeps your dog happy and relaxed.

Customer Testimonials

We entered into the dog toy space with a mission to create durable, high-quality toys that could stand up to even the most enthusiastic chewers. Our customers have shared countless stories of their experiences with our products, highlighting how our commitment to durability and quality has made a difference in their lives and their dogs happiness.

One customer, Sierra from Alberta, told us:

My pup loves all the toys that come in the box, he’s a Cane Corso, and they withstand his powerful chewing.

Another customer, Mackenzie from Ontario shared:

DuraPaw is our new favorite monthly subscription box. The Rippable toys are fantastic to keep our boy occupied.

These testimonials reflect our dedication to providing pet owners with reliable, durable, and high-quality dog toys that offer both fun and peace of mind. Hearing from our satisfied customers motivates us to continue innovating and maintaining the highest standards in the industry.


While the term "indestructible dog toys" can be a bit misleading, being aware of how to find the best-suited toys for your power chewer can increase the longevity and safety of their playthings. Look for high-quality materials, appropriate sizing, and designs specifically made for tough chewers. Investing in these durable toys will provide your furry friend with hours of fun and mental stimulation while giving you peace of mind. Remember, the goal is to find toys that are as tough as your dog, ensuring they stay happy and healthy.